Welcome back to the Setting Spray showdown! This is the third and fourth (last!) round in my setting spray showdown series, where I’m testing popular formulas side by side to see what actually makes a difference in real life. I’ll be doing the same makeup, with the same lighting, for at least 16 hours for each test. I’ve also been testing all of these setting sprays for months before doing these elimination rounds. For these rounds, I did all of the matches in one post since I’ve already talked about each spray at length in previous posts. In this post, all links are affiliate links (thank you for your support!), but all opinions are my own.
Round 3, Match 1: MAC Fix+ Stay Over vs Danessa Myricks Blurring Balm Spray – Obviously, since we’re at the final four, all of these are beautiful and genuinely great setting sprays, and I would repurchase all of them again and again. Mac Fix+ Stay Over is one of my all time faves, and I’ll keep repurchasing it, especially for my super dry skin days. But if I’m being super picky, Danessa Myricks is the one that’s moving forward in the showdown. I tested these side by side on different days and switched sides to make sure. Both times the Danessa side looked smoother and more blurred without being too matte. It photographed better, it looked better in person, and it kept my makeup looking great consistently throughout the day. I continue to be surprised how well the Danessa works with my dry skin, even in winter.
Round 3, Match 2: Milani Make It Last Dewy vs Hourglass Veil Soft Focus – These both looked great, as expected, and I really do think the Hourglass spray is amazing for a soft focus finish. If I really had to choose, the Milani side held up better throughout the day and just looked slihtly more hydrated and smoother. I also did side by sides over two days and switched the sides to make super sure like I did with the first match. In photos and in person, everyone picked the Milani side both days. That said, I’m sure from a distance that you wouldn’t be able to tell the difference between these two. Given how much less expensive the Milani is, it’s an easy choice to move it on when it held up so well to (and honestly did better than) the Hourglass.
Round 4: Danessa Myricks Blurring Balm Spray vs Milani Make It Last Dewy – I tested these against each other for a bunch of days so I could switch the sides each spray was on and see how they worked with different makeup. Surprisingly, the same spray won every time even though it was very close. I did get a couple of “those are the same” responses, which is good news given these are the final 2! Both sprays gave me that blurred, smooth look and helped my makeup last all day, but one side always just a little looked better in photos and in person (as always, no one I knew which side was which). That side looked more natural, my makeup looked more intact at the end of the day, and my skin looked dewier without an overly glassy finish or looking like I had a film on my face.
So especially if you have dry skin, Milani Make It Last Dewy is the final winner! One caveat – the sprayer is not a luxury experience, and it’s the one thing that really bugs me about the Milani. Given how much less expensive it is than many of the others, I’d be willing to buy a nicer spray bottle to put it into (and probably will). The Danessa Myricks spray is also still incredible, and I think you’d be really happy with it particularly if you have combo to oily skin. My oily-skin friends have confirmed it’s amazing for them. Honestly, I’d still recommend most of the setting sprays I tested, and definitely any in the top four. I’m excited to have the more matte and blurring ones for summer and the dewy ones this winter!
What other products would you like me to review? Let me know if there’s anything else you’d like to see here, and thanks for reading! As always, some links may be affiliate links that support the blog, but all reviews/opinions are completely my own and unsponsored.
Makeup and Skincare Reviews 