My Chat Wanted Reviews on Blue things, a bunch of blush, and an eyeshadow from YesStyle 

I’ve been aksing my chat for requests for what to get in my fairly frequent YesStyle review orders, and this order was 100% picked by chat. I posted my order when it got here, and folks voted on what they wanted me to review first so I’m doing that for my “things you asked me to test post” for August. I normally try to spend at least a few weeks, if not a few months, testing things before I write about them. This post is a little late because I wanted to test each of these products at least a few times, and it’s still technically August! If you’d like me to review anything else from YesStyle (or anywhere else), leave a comment or join the chat – we’d be happy to have you!

In this post, all links are affiliate links (thank you for your support!), but all opinions are my own and I bought all these products myself. I also have a YesStyle and Stylevana favorites shelf on my ShopMy if you want to see more of the products I’ve tried and would recommend. Swatches are under a ring light to show true to color (photo #1) and then standard lighting to show the formula a little better (#2) for all the products.

Gege Bear Brightening Concealer in 02 Frost Blue – I’m not sure I’ve ever actually talked about this before, even though the one in this order is actually a backup because I’m almost through my first tube. This is one of my favorite and most used products for fixing foundation that’s a little too dark and/or too orange on me. I usually put my foundation on first, add a few tiny dots of this directly on top, and blend it in with a brush. It cancels out the orange just enough, adds a little brightness, and makes everything just a little more green. Perfect match every time from a not so perfect match. I’ve never noticed it changing the texture or finish of my foundation at all. I have other blue correctors I like, but this is so cheap and works so well that I will absolutely keep buying it again and again. I also do use the green version of this as an actual color corrector where I have redness before I put on foundation.

Gege Bear Water Light Mirror Lip Gloss in 01 – This gloss does have enough blue pigment to actually cool down a lipstick that’s pulling too orange on me, but it’s still sheer enough that I can wear it by itself without looking like I’m wearing a BLUE lip gloss. It also has a ton of really pretty sparkle that doesn’t feel gritty or chunky that makes my lips look really nice. The formula and packaging are very clearly inspired by the Risky Be Bold Lip Glosses I’ve reviewed before (or at least it seems that way looking at them side by side; maybe it’s not inspired by Risky at all). I do still think the Risky gloss is ultimately a better formula. It’s more moisturizing and smoothing, and the Gege Bear feels thinner and less nourishing. Gege Bear is around $5 though compared to $19 for Risky, and I really do love the color, so I’m not mad about the formula difference. 

I’M MEME I’m Multi Stick Blusher in 005 Bliss Mauve and 006 Blooming Lilac – The formula of these blushes feels exactly the same to me as the shading stick that I reviewed in my last post. It’s super easy to blend with a brush or fingers, I can swipe them directly onto my face without it getting patchy, and the formula has a slightly blurring finish that I really love. My face also doesn’t eat this formula super quickly like it does with some other cream products. 

Bliss Mauve is not mauve at all on me – it’s just pink. Importantly, it stays pink on my face instead of going orange or coral, and it has enough saturation to actually show up on me as someone who is high contrast. It brightens up my face really well is a really good base layer for when I want to do a pink blush look and don’t want to have to worry about powder fading as fast. Blooming Lilac is a bright, pale lilac with a lot of white in it. I honestly have only been able to use this as a mixer to make another blush lighter and cooler. This is one of the few non-shimmery formulas in this color I’ve found because it does feel more like a highlighter. I think it’s really unique for that reason. I also do think there are people who will love this as an actual blush, especially if you’ve been looking for something this color and have never been able to find it. 

House of Hur Moist Ampoule Blusher in Lavender Flush and Cherry Blossom – I already had Rose Brown and Berry Purple, and then someone in chat asked what some of the other shades looked like as I was putting this order together, so I picked up Lavender Flush and Cherry Blossom. This formula is super sheer and watercolory, so I was actually a little worried about Lavender Flush when I swatched it because it looked like it might do basically nothing on my face. Once I put it on, I loved it. It’s very much a barely there blush on me, but somehow I just look prettier and more put together with it on.

Cherry Blossom is a little more pigmented and way warmer on me. It definitely goes pinky coral, but luckily it doesn’t go full Cheeto orange. I really like it when I’m intentionally doing a bronzy/warm look because it brightens up my face and is warm without going too much in that direction. This formula also blends out super easily with a brush, and it’s basically impossible to put too much on, which is perfect with a brighter color like this one.

Laka Bonding Glow Lipstick in 202 Boy and 217 Babe – Boy is honestly so special, and everyone in my chat who’s gotten it so far would agree. It’s a little brown, a little gray, a little purple, and stays cool toned on me. Boy also has that same kind of muted, slightly grungy feeling as MAC Alone Time (original shade!) while being even cooler toned. I swatched them next to each other and Boy actually makes the original Alone Time look warm. Babe is a really good pink, and I’m happy I bought it. I’ve been wearing it with mauve and lavender looks when I want something a little brighter on my lips, and it stays pink on me instead of going orange. It’s just really easy to wear, and I’m glad y’all asked me to test it.

I honestly forgot how much I love this lipstick formula until I started testing these again for this post. Both shades are now sitting at the front of my makeup station because my lips just look so good with them on. It’s moisturizing and glossy enough to make my lips look much smoother without being too shiny or sticky. The color also lasts pretty well considering this isn’t a matte lipstick or a stain, and it’s pretty easy to build up the level of pigment without it getting weird. My lips just look better when I wear this lipstick. There’s a little bit of a fruity scent, but it doesn’t last very long, and I can’t taste it at all.

Laka Mono Eyeshadow in 926 Liberty – I was super excited about this one because it seemed like it could be Urban Decay Space Cowboy, but not orange. And I was right! This shadow is so sparkly and pretty. It has a neutral brown base with a ton of silver sparkle, but the thing I like most about it is that the brown actually stays neutral. I swatched it next to Urban Decay Space Cowboy so you can see how not orange Liberty is. On my eyes, it actually pulls a little cooler than it does in the swatch which almost never happens. With a lighter layer, you can see more of the brown base, and if you build it up, it gets much more silvery. It’s sheer enough that it works well as a topper, and I’ve used both a brush and a finger to apply this shadow without any problems.

Laka Mono Eyeshadow in 926 Liberty, Urban Decay Space Cowboy
Laka Mono Eyeshadow in 926 Liberty, Urban Decay Space Cowboy

That all said, I would absolutely use a primer with this eyeshadow. I tested it with primer on one eye and nothing on the other, and the side without primer had a ton of fallout. The primer side was almost entirely fallout free so it definitely made a big difference. 

What should I test for the next round?

The Makeup I Packed for a Week Away, and How I (Try To) Avoid Overpacking my Makeup 

I recently went away for about a week to visit family, and since it was super hot and humid and I knew I was mostly going to be doing pretty casual makeup, I tried to pack things that were easy, reliable, and all worked together. I only ended up wearing makeup about half the days, and when I did, it was the same 15-minute look every time.

This is honestly a pretty normal amount of travel makeup for me. I really don’t like to overpack makeup (especially now that I have to bring all of my toddler’s stuff). I don’t like bringing anything huge that would make it difficult to stuff back in a bag or so expensive that I’m going to be upset if something happens to it. I always pick my blushes first and then everything else has to work with them. For this trip I started with Lilybyred 14 and NAMING Taro, so that immediately ruled out anything too warm or orange. Everything else ended up being some version of mauve, beige, pink, or neutral brown. 

In this post, all links are affiliate links (thank you for your support!), but all opinions are my own and I bought all these products myself. Swatches are under a ring light to show true to color (photo #1) and then standard lighting to show the formula a little better (#2) for all the products. 

Afform Medium Traveller – I bought this a couple of years ago and I’ve taken it on basically every trip since. I love this bag so much. It has a ton of pockets in different sizes, including stretchy mesh ones that you can really fit a lot in. Some of the compartments are adjustable with Velcro in case you want to create more (or less) space. The rigid bottom is probably my favorite part because everything stays standing up in the bag. The sides also fold down, so I can open this on the counter and use my makeup straight out of it. I don’t have to create a giant makeup explosion in whatever room I’m in and can just zip it all back up.  

All of the makeup in this post fit super easily with lots of room, so I could also add in my BK Beauty travel brush bag with all my brushes too. I’ve never had anything break or leak all over it, and it’s held up really well after years of travel. It’s absolutely very expensive for a makeup bag but I would also immediately buy another one if I lost it, no questions asked. 

Glow Recipe Watermelon Glow Niacinamide Dew Drops – I use this as my usual primer at home and have the jumbo bottle because it’s such a standby for me. I happened to have a couple minis on hand already that were either gifts with purchase or came with sets. These are perfect for travel, and not surprisingly, it worked just as well away as it does at home. 

Erborian CC Red Correct – This was a super easy choice to bring as my foundation because I didn’t want to have to worry about something that perfectly matched me. Most all my foundations need a little something to look just right, and I don’t want to have to bring things to fix a foundation when I’m travelling. I had also just been using this a ton as a base layer anyway before I got my current foundation favorite (the new Westman Atelier – I seriously can’t stop wearing it). 

This mostly just gets rid of redness and evens everything out, and I am honestly green enough that using a green color corrector as foundation works completely fine. It’s not very high coverage (you can barely see it in the swatches), but I didn’t really want high coverage when it was approximately one million degrees outside anyway. It held up really well, it has SPF, and the tube takes up barely any space. 

Kulfi Main Match Concealer in Paan Party – I’m currently using so many different concealers because I’m putting together a concealer tournament. I just picked one from the pile I knew was easy and hoped for the best. Paan Party works well for me as a brightening concealer, the formula is really blendable, and it works well under my eyes. It wasn’t necessarily the concealer I would have picked if I were trying to find my absolute perfect shade match, and this doesn’t mean it won anything. It did work perfectly well and is still one I’d recommend though. 

Canmake Marshmallow Finish Powder Abloom in 03 Plumeria Wreath – I always pack this powder. It’s my much less expensive version of the Givenchy pressed powder and one I can bring without worrying about. On my face, they do almost the same thing, and many of you who have bought this powder have told me you love it too. It smooths and brightens without making my dry skin look super powdery and helps blend everything together.

MAC Fix+ Stay Over – I had a mini of this literally in my bag already from my last trip, so I brought it as my setting spray. It didn’t win my setting spray tournament, but it still works really well and definitely didn’t disappoint during the trip. 

I’m Meme I’m Multi Stick Shading in 005 Neutral Brown – I love this as a brontour type product. It’s actually neutral and not warm or cool on me like most of these products are (I tend to find things that are ORANGE or GRAY). I love how travel friendly the stick is, and I can apply directly from the stick or with a brush. It blends out really easily, and I like it so much I already have the blush version on the way to try out.

Soshe Blurring Pillow Bronzer in Olive Bronze Drift – I know I just talked about this last week but I really do love the formula enough that it was the bronzer I brought with me. Olive Bronze Drift isn’t my perfect bronzer color of all time, but it’s a really nice option for olive skin and I don’t have to worry about something like the Marc Jacobs bronzer getting broken on a trip. 

Judydoll Highlight & Contour Palette in #02 – This is such an underrated palette. I used the beigey yellow powder to blend and set anywhere where I needed a little more coverage than the Canmake, the highlighter as my highlighter, and the powders when I wanted to blur and mattify my bronzer even more. You can see the bronzer shade is super similar to Olive Bronze Drift but a little less orange, so next time, I’d probably just bring this palette. 

Lilybyred Luv Beam Cheek Balm in 14 Rosy Beam – I also just talked about this last week, but it’s really such a perfect cream blush for the vibe I’m going for. It’s a cool pinky purple that’s just so extremely easy to use and doesn’t turn into anything close to orange on me. I almost always put powder blush over cream blush anyway, and this works really well as the first layer because it gives me the color I want without getting too intense. Those of you who have managed to already get this from last week’s post have told me it’s one of the best blushes you’ve found for olive skin, and that makes me so happy! 

Naming Fluffy Powder Blush in Taro – This is one of my favorite powder blushes of all time. It looks like a very desaturated mauve in the pan but is a perfect beigey rosy blush on my face. I know this blush is always going to look good, so this was the starting point for the rest of the look. The formula is also really easy to throw on and build up and looks so pretty on the cheeks. 

Makeup by Mario Master Mattes Long-Wear Cream Eyeshadow in Mauve – This is the eyeshadow I’ve brought with me on every trip since I bought it. It’s just so easy to throw on with a finger, blend it out, and then be done. It makes a complete makeup look without being “too much” and looks super natural while covering up the discoloration on my eyelid, so I don’t need a primer. It’s more of a neutral brown with a touch of rosy tones than a true mauve, but that still works really well as a “I put something on but didn’t try too hard” kind of shadow, especially with these blushes. It also stayed on all day in the heat and humidity without creasing. I also intended to use this as an eyeshadow primer for the Moira shadow, but it looked so nice I just stopped here every time. 

Moira Chroma Light Shadow in 02 Tempting – I brought this because I thought I would want sparkle, and I just didn’t end up using it. I would probably still pack it again because it’s tiny and I really do love the formula and the color. 

ColourPop Creme Gel Liner in Sunnyvale – This is my favorite affordable brown eyeliner. I have much more expensive eyeliners I love, but this works great and it’s not a huge deal if I have to replace it. It’s a really good dark brown liner that isn’t too warm or too cool, and it has amazing staying power. It held up incredibly well on my eyes in the heat and humidity. 

Maybelline Lash Sensational Sky Tubes Tubing Mascara in Black – I’m actually in the middle of testing so I figured East Coast summer was a perfect time to continue testing. I’m always trying to find an even better tubing mascara, and this one is actually really great. No smudging, no flaking, my lashes looked incredible, and it’s really easy to remove. It’s everything I want from a tubing mascara, and it’s affordable. I think this probably knocks Finding Ferdinand out of my top three tubing mascaras, even though I still really love that one.

rephr Eyelash Curler – My favorite eyelash curler. It works with my eye shape, doesn’t pinch me, and actually gets my corner lashes. 10/10 no notes. 

Benefit Precisely, My Brow Pencil in 5 – This is the brow pencil I’ve been using for years and always have with me. It’s  the best one I’ve found for actually sticking to the skin where I need to fill in my brows and have it stay all day. If you have recommendations for amazing brow pencils, please let me know in the comments because I will test it (I have a lot of brow space to fill in because I have a big chunk of missing brow from a childhood accident). 

Rare Beauty Brow Harmony Flexible Lifting Gel in Clear – Still the best clear brow gel. It keeps my eyebrows where I put them and doesn’t get weird and crunchy. I’m currently resting the deep brown version and couldn’t be happier with it. 

ColourPop HydraPop Glossy Lip Stain in 90s Babe – All of these products have been sitting in a pile on my floor while I’ve been working on this post, and I have gone back specifically to pull this out of the pile and wear it. It’s a super pretty reddish rose that just looks like my lips but better. I have more on why I love this and swatches here. Mostly, it’s super easy to throw on and the stain lasts really well. 

Revlon Super Lustrous Shine Lipstick in 014 Glistening Purple – This is the lip product I ended up wearing the most. It’s a sheerish wash of lavender that really pulls this look together and makes my lips look just a little less red and a little more muted. I’m currently testing the Chantecaille Lip Chics, and those are honestly way more nourishing and last better than the Revlon formula. I’m not trying to imply that this is secretly the same experience as a $50 lipstick, but I really, really love this Revlon color so much that I would absolutely buy it again. The formula is still really nice and nourishing even though it isn’t luxury

OleHenriksen Pout Preserve Chillers Peptide Lip Treatment in Maldives Melon – This is one of my favorite lip treatments of all time (and it’s on sale!). I own almost every color/scent/glitter ones even, and I keep them all over my house. I actually had more Pout Preserves in my backpack for this trip. I used this for lip prep and whenever my lips were dry. Maldives Melon Chiller also just smells really nice, and I like the color. I think I like the color of Bora Bora Blackberry Chiller more but they’re not opaque enough that it makes a huge difference. 

And the lip products I love but didn’t use: 

Etude Fixing Tint in 15 Woody Pink – I didn’t use it, but I would still pack it again. If I were only bringing one matte option next time, this would be it. I love this formula too much not to have one with me just in case.

Mac Powder Kiss Lip + Cheek Mousse in Velvet Teddy – I love this product so much. I didn’t even remember I brought it.  

NYX Lip Lingerie Lip Liner Stain in 06 Up To No Good – I really love this. I also didn’t use it at all and didn’t even consider wearing lip liner.  If I packed again, I would pack almost entirely the same products, except for the MAC mousse and NYX stain. 

What’s your makeup packing routine like?

The Makeup I’m Using (Almost) Every Day That I Haven’t Had a Chance To Talk About Yet

I wanted to do a post about the products I’ve actually been reaching for over and over when I’m not testing something else. These are the things I’ve been using almost every day, even if they aren’t perfect. They’re super reliable and easy to use, and they also just make me feel pretty and put together with very little work.

In this post, all links are affiliate links (thank you for your support!), but all opinions are my own and I bought all these products myself. Swatches are under a ring light to show true to color (photo #1) and then standard lighting to show the formula a little better (#2) for all the products. 

L’Oréal True Match Super-Blendable Foundation in W2.5 – My arm swatches were not doing this shade justice so I decided to show a photo of half my face with and without the foundation instead. Hopefully it’s easier to see how it actually looks on me. I did a side by side of the photo and then the same photo with this very professional green line so you can see exactly where the foundation starts – it’s on the bottom half of my face. W2.5 is described as a warm light-medium, and it’s a touch too yellow and a touch too deep for me, but it blends into my neck really well. If I weren’t nitpicking the match because I test so many base products, I probably wouldn’t notice. That said, it also definitely doesn’t turn Cheeto orange on me like a lot of foundations described as warm do and so I don’t have to color correct which is awesome. I would skip this particular shade if you’re a cool olive, but if you’re a more saturated warm olive, I think it’s a really good option.

The formula is also just really nice. It self-sets, smooths out my skin, and gives me enough coverage to make a difference without looking like a lot of foundation. You can hopefully see in the photo it color corrects the redness on my face and makes everything match my neck while being pretty imperceptible. It’s basically what I want out of a skin tint, except with more coverage, and it happens to also be affordable.

Lilybyred Luv Beam Cheek Balm in 14 – I was using the Leemember Cheek and Lip Cream in Y03 a bunch before I got this and thought that was a pretty perfect blush color for me. Until I tried the Lilybyred, which is actually the perfect blush color for me. The Lilybyred is a much cooler pinky purple and just works so much better with my skin. The formula is also really easy to use with a brush or fingers and lasts pretty well for a cheek balm. It also works by itself or as a base for another blush without having issues layering. I’ve been so pleasantly surprised by how much use I’ve been getting out of this one. 

Soshe Blurring Pillow Bronzers in Bronze Linen, Olive Bronze Drift, Bronze Speakeasy, and Bronze Dusk – I already love the Soshe blushes so much, and these are that same really lightweight cream to powder formula that is my personal favorite. They’re really easy to blend, super blurring, and set down nicely without looking too dry. I’ve mostly been wearing Olive Bronze Drift and Bronze Dusk as bronzers and Bronze Speakeasy as a blush. Bronze Linen isn’t quite right for me because it’s too peachy orange, and I can confirm it also goes orange on some of my green, blue, and purple friends. Most shades are sold out on Soshe’s site but Ulta has almost all of them right now!

Soshe Bronze Linen, Olive Bronze Drift, Bronze Speakeasy, and Bronze Dusk
Soshe Bronze Linen, Olive Bronze Drift, Bronze Speakeasy, and Bronze Dusk

I also swatched Giorgio Armani Luminous Silk Bronzing Powder in 90, Olive Bronze Drift, Bronze Dusk, and Marc Jacobs Legally Bronze Powder Bronzer in 20 next to each other since they’re all pretty similar. Marc Jacobs in 20 is actually the most traditionally bronzey on me and this helped me see why I still love that one so much. It has enough brown warmth so that it looks like what I expect bronzer to look like on my skin without going too orange (Armani), green (Olive Bronze Drift), or rosy (Bronze Dusk). If I could have Marc Jacobs 20 in the Soshe formula, I’d be so happy. That said, these are all great on me and blended out, it’s really hard to tell the nuanced differences between them.

I also swatched Gucci Bronzing Powder in 02 and 01, Fara Homidi Essential Bronzer in Bois, Bronze Linen, and Bronze Speakeasy so you can see how the rosier shades look against a couple popular rosier bronzers. Honestly right now in the summer, none of these is a good bronzer shade for me. Gucci 02 and Linen are definitely too orange or peachy, and the other three can all be used as blushes or transition type powders.  

Bobbi Brown Crystal Eyes Shadow Stick in Pink – I wouldn’t necessarily recommend this one if you want to wear it by itself because it can get a little patchy, but I really like it as a topper. This is one of the sparkliest eyeshadows I own, and I’ve been throwing it on constantly. It’s definitely a super chunky glitter formula rather than a smooth shimmer so I would skip this if you’re not into a chunky glitter. I personally am very into this level of sparkle right now.  

It has pretty good staying power, but honestly it’s so sparkly that I don’t really care if it moves around or creases a little. These swatches are absolutely not doing it justice. I have one of the darker shades as well and find that one even patchier and harder to apply, so I’m still not sure I would recommend every shade in the formula. Pink specifically is really easy to use and stays a really pretty pink instead of going orange or peach on me. Did I mention it’s just really sparkly and glittery? 

What have you been reaching for lately?

I Bought A Bunch of Lisa Eldridge’s Olive Edit So You Don’t Have To

I’m a yellow-green (very green), slightly saturated olive. A lot of products that are technically olive still pull too gray, too orange, too peach, or just slightly off on me. So when someone shared that Lisa Eldridge had a whole olive edit that you can sort by depth and saturation level with a ton of her products categorized, I knew I needed to do a haul for y’all. I grabbed all of the olive skin tints, a couple lipsticks, 4 of the new blush sticks, a concealer pencil, a balm highlighter, and a few eyeshadow singles to test. 

In this post, all links are affiliate links (thank you for your support!), but all opinions are my own and I bought all these products myself. Swatches are under a ring light to show true to color (photo #1) and then standard lighting to show the formula a little better (#2) for all the products.

Quick note on swatches: my arm is not the same color as my face, and I’m using arm swatches mostly to show undertone, depth, and how the shades compare to each other but rest assured these really blend into my skin if I say it’s a great match. 

Lisa Eldridge Seamless Skin Enhancing Tint in T1.5, T5, and T9 – I’ve loved this formula for years. My original shade was T4, which was good but not quite right, and I still wore it constantly because the formula is exactly what I want from a skin tint. It’s lightweight, easy to rub in with just your fingers, super flattering, and weirdly durable for something that looks this natural. I remember testing this when I was pregnant, and it survived through many, many long and rough days and still looked amazing. 

I originally started this time with the shade T5, because I figured T4 but olive would work the best. T5 is definitely olive, but it’s much more cool olive than Iam. It has that gray-green, desaturated quality that works for a lot of olives, but my skin is more yellow-green and saturated. I can get away with it because the formula is sheer, but it’s definitely not my perfect shade.

T1.5, T5, and T9
T1.5, T5, and T9

A lot of people suggested mixing T5 with T9 because T9 has a warmer olive undertone, and so I bought T9. T9 is so much deeper than my skin that even though the undertone is better in some ways, it can read orange on me because it’s just too dark (though the undertone is still much better than some other foundations I’ve tried).

Then other people told me to try T1.5, which is the lightest and only other olive skin tint. It’s too light and bright for me on its own, especially in the summer, but it turned out to be the key to making the others work. My best match is T1.5 mixed with T5, which gets me closest to the right balance of lightness and green without going grey or orange. You can barely see it on my face. T1.5 mixed with T9 also works surprisingly well on my face, though I’d still be tempted to add a tiny bit of blue. T5 mixed with T9 with a light blue color corrector also does work, so all of these will get used. 

T1.5, T5, and Mixed
T1.5 and T9 mixed; T5 and T9 mixed

That all said, my favorite thing about this experiment was finding out that T1.5 fixes almost any base product. I’ve mixed it into foundations that were a little too dark, a little too orange, or both, and suddenly they looked right. I also like using it as a first layer, almost like a skin-perfecting primer, before putting another foundation on top and every shade looks great now. If Lisa wants to send me a giant bottle of the tint in 1.5, I would definitely not say no.

Lisa Eldridge Velatura Balm Dewy Lip and Cheek Stick in Cinnamon Bun, Hellebore Heaven, Rose Madder, and Meeting The Ex – I started with Cinnamon Bun and Hellebore Heaven and liked them so much that I picked up Rose Madder and Meeting The Ex too. Cinnamon Bun, Hellebore Heaven, and Rose Madder are all on the Lisa Eldridge olive page for light-medium saturated olives. Meeting The Ex isn’t but I’m formally requesting it be added. The formula is incredibly easy to use on both lips and cheeks. They’ve become one of my go to lip balms when I just want a little color but I want it to be easy and just look nice. On my cheeks, I especially like tapping these on top of powder when I want to bring some glow back. They don’t last all day, but they’re so easy and pretty that I don’t really mind.

Cinnamon Bun, Hellebore Haven, Rose Madder, and Meeting the Ex

Cinnamon Bun, Hellebore Haven, Rose Madder, and Meeting the Ex

Cinnamon Bun is one of my favorite blonzer shades. It’s warm, but not Cheeto orange, and gives me that rusty red-brown “I went outside and got a little color” flush. It’s just super easy to throw on and look put together. Hellebore Heaven is my favorite of the four. It’s a beautiful everyday berry that I know will work in winter, spring, fall, and even for a summer berry look. It gives me that olive-friendly berry flush without turning muddy or weirdly red. Rose Madder and Meeting The Ex are pretty close, and I don’t think you need both. Rose Madder is more neutral and almost warm coral pink on me. It’s nice, but it’s the one I’d give up first. Meeting The Ex is brighter, cooler, and more baby blue pink, and I actually like it better. I think warmer olives look really good in brighter cool pinks, especially when neutral pinks turn weirdly warm or flat.

Lisa Eldridge Pinpoint Concealer Micro Correcting Pencil in 5.5 – This is my favorite spot concealer product. I’ve especially been using it around the outside of my lips after seeing Lisa Eldridge show that trick as a way to naturally create a “lifted lip look”, and now I do it constantly. It just cleans everything up and makes my lips stand out more. I also reach for this if I have one tiny spot or one tiny area I want to perfect. I really like this concealer for when I need more control and just want something to seamlessly blend into my skin. I have some swatches here, but it really does blend into my skin so well.

Lisa Eldridge Luxuriously Lucent Lip Colour in Meet Me In Berlin and Rouge Experience Refillable Lipstick in Toasted – I know lips are Lisa Eldridge’s thing so you might be surprised to only find two here. I used to own a ton of her lipsticks, but most of them expired by now, and I also realized that a lot of shades I thought worked on me didn’t actually look as good as I thought they did. For this review, I bought Meet Me In Berlin and Toasted because both are recommended on the olive page, and they were the ones I was the most suspicious of. They looked like the kind of colors that could go orange on me very quickly or stay a pretty beige.

Meet Me in Berlin and Toasted
Meet Me in Berlin and Toasted

Swatched next to MAC Alone Time (old version), you can see why I was nervous. Alone Time (again, original version, I’m looking for dupes!) is more muted, gray-purple, and grungy, which is my favorite kind of lip product. Meet Me In Berlin and Toasted are both warmer and more tan, but they still have enough rosy terracotta that they don’t turn completely orange.

Alone Time, Meet Me In Berlin, Toasted

Meet Me In Berlin is still a product I throw on without thinking too hard, and the formula is a super comfy balmy formula that you can build up if you want. The Rouge Experience formula is easy to wear even though it’s much more of a traditional satin lipstick than the balm texture of the Luxuriously Lucent Lip. It does have a really pretty soft sheen still and wears really comfortably during the day. The packaging also makes it one of the most luxurious feeling lipsticks I own, though I have it on good authority you can make do with just the refills or one case and refills.

Lisa Eldridge Eyeshadow Singles in Chrysina, Ablaze, and Posh – I own way too much eyeshadow to justify buying more full palettes or a bunch of liquid shadows unless y’all request it (like how Makeup by Mario is launching new liquid eyeshadows and I will be picking a couple up to test). So for this review, I bought a few singles from the Lisa Eldridge palettes recommended for olives, Betty and Desert Gleam. I picked up Chrysina, Ablaze, and Posh, and all three are in the smooth, sparkly, shimmery formula I love. Honestly, if Lisa made a whole palette of this exact finish, I would probably buy it. 

Chrysina, Ablaze, and Posh
Chrysina, Ablaze, and Posh

Chrysina is a sheer golden-green topper. It barely has a base, so I can put it over basically anything when I want the look to feel a little more at home on my olive skin. It’s pretty and useful, but because it’s sheer and toppery, it reminds me of a lot of other shades I already own. Ablaze is the most classic warm shade of the three. It’s coppery and bronzy, and I like it, but I wish it had a little more rose in it to work better with my skin. Posh is easily my favorite. It’s a mauve purple shimmery brown, and it’s exactly the kind of everyday shade I want. It has more pinky taupe to it than Ablaze, which is why it works better for me.

Lisa Eldridge Elevated Glow Balm Concentrate in Butterfly Light – I spent an unreasonable amount of time trying to photograph my swatch of Butterfly Light, and I’m sorry, but I just couldn’t do it. I tried photos, videos, indoor light, outdoor light, and it just wouldn’t show up in any kind of useful way. The best way I can describe it is: if you took my arm color, made it pinker/blushier, and added a little shine, that’s Butterfly Light. It’s pretty, and I’m not upset that I bought it. It gives a soft rosy highlight, and I like tapping it on when I want a little more glow. The packaging is also lovely. But it’s definitely just a highlighter balm. It’s sheer, shiny, and a little balmy on the skin.

Of everything I bought for this review, this is the one I’d give up first. If you’re already placing an order and want a soft rosy highlight balm, I don’t think you’d hate it, and I know a couple folks that really love it . But I wouldn’t buy it again over the highlighters I already have (and to be fair to Lisa, it’s not on the olive edit page anyway!).

Have you tried Lisa Eldridge’s olive recommendations yet?

National Lipstick Day Awards: Everyday Favorites, Worth It Splurges, and the Lipstick I’m Still Trying to Dupe 

National Lipstick Day is tomorrow so I went through all of my lipsticks and retried everything to give out awards (seriously, my lips may never recover from this, but worth it for y’all!). For this post, I’m counting traditional lipsticks, stick and clicky lip products, liquid lipsticks, and stains. I left out regular glosses, balms in a squeeze tube, or anything like that unless it leaves an actual stain. I’m also not choosing the best overall lipstick. I tried, and you can’t make me. Also, lots of these are on sale right now for National Lipstick Day/Week if you happen to be in the market – some of them are even 50% off. 

In this post, all links are affiliate links (thank you for your support!), but all opinions are my own. Swatches are under a ring light to show true to color (photo #1) and then standard lighting to show the formula a little better (#2) for all the products. 

Best Everyday Lipstick: Ravie Beauty Effortless Lips in Dahlia and Zinnia – These are creamy and almost balmy, but they still feel like proper satin lipsticks with good pigmentation and staying power. Dahlia is my perfect everyday pink that doesn’t pull warm, while Zinnia is a berry brown that doesn’t turn orange. Both work with almost every makeup look I tend to do. They’re too pigmented to apply without a mirror, but the shape of the bullet makes getting a precise application much easier.

The Forever Standby: YSL Candy Glaze in 15 and 16 – These have maintained a permanent spot on my desk longer than anything else. This is the most moisturizing and nourishing formula in this post, and it feels much closer to a tinted lip treatment than a traditional lipstick. I even own the clear version for when my lips are dry, but shades 15 and 16 give me the same comfort with enough color to make me look more put together. 

Best Jacket Pocket/Purse Lip: Makeup by Mario MoistureGlow Plumping Lip Serum in Honey Glow and Mocha Glow – Honey Glow gives me a sheer wash of pinky brown, while Mocha Glow is a deeper rosy brown and would be my pick if I only bought one. The formula is shiny, nourishing, and lightly minty and plumping, so I can throw it on without a mirror and immediately look more put together and hydrated. I’ve never had one melt or open in a bag even though they’ve travelled far with me. The only thing is they don’t retract, so only click up as much as you need.

Best “Oh no, I Need to Put Something on for This Meeting” Lip: JOOCYEE Long-Lasting Glossy Rouge in Diamond Sea – This is what I grab when I suddenly realize I have to be on camera and need to look more alive and awake immediately. Diamond Sea is such an easy cool mauvey pink with subtle sparkle, and the formula is moisturizing enough that my lips always look and feel better after I apply it. It’s flattering, fast, and requires almost no thought.

Most Worth the Splurge: Westman Atelier HydroBalm Tinted Lipsticks in Soda and Onyx – Every time I put either of these on, I immediately think “damn, that looks good” which is very rare for me. Soda is a more pigmented cool brown, while Onyx is a sheer deep purple brown that gives me the cherry berry effect I’m always trying to find. The formula is sheer enough to be easy but still has enough pigment to feel like an actual lipstick and not just a tinted balm. These are moisturizing, but they feel more like beautiful lipsticks that also make my lips feel better. The YSL Candy Glazes are more like lip treatments that also happen to be pretty. The Westman Atelier lipsticks are slightly minty and extremely expensive, but they would still be some of the first products I replaced if I lost my collection.

Prettiest Packaging: Lisa Eldridge Rouge Experience Refillable Lipstick in Toasted – I went through all of my lipsticks for this post, and nothing else made me think that I was really getting a luxury experience. The shape, satisfying weight, and refillable case make applying this lipstick feel genuinely special and fancy.Toasted is a beige that actually stays fairly beige on me, although it is warmer than something like the original MAC Alone time. I know in the photos it looks pretty orange, but when it mixes with my natural lip color, it works out. The Rouge Experience formula is easy to wear even though it’s much more of a traditional satin lipstick than balm texture. It does have a really pretty soft sheen still and wears really comfortably during the day. It works with or without liner, and doesn’t dry out my lips. I like the formula enough that I’m considering getting more shades, so this isn’t beautiful packaging compensating for a mediocre lipstick. The packaging is definitely the prettiest though by far. 

The Discontinued Lipstick I’m Still Trying to Dupe: Hermès Prunoir –  This is truly the perfect lipstick when I’m doing a berry toned or mauvey toned or purple leaning look because it’s such a pretty not too light not too dark sheer cool toned mauvey berry. It’s also incredible as a way to balance out lipsticks that just need a bit of purple added to them when it feels like something is off. The formula is also perfect. It’s shiny and hydrating without sliding all over the place, and it’s sheer without being patchy or not really showing up. The only thing is that it really has that luxury lip scent that’s quite strong, but I’ll put up with it for how perfect it is otherwise.  I’ve tried so many lipsticks and balms that looked like they might replace Prunoir, and every single time I think I’ve finally found something close, it isn’t the same. I’m cherishing my tube forever. I’m seriously still looking for a dupe, so please tell me if you have any dupe ideas. My very lovely friend told me to try out the Chantecaille Lip Chic in Wisteria which look very close and is on sale, so stay tuned!

Best Black Honey for Olive Skin: ColourPop Hyper Shine Glossy Lipstick in DND – Clinique Black Honey turns orange on me, which is not what I picture when I think of a sheer blackberry lip. DND is a sheer black that stays deep, cool, and purpley berry, and I can either blot it down or build it up depending on how dramatic I want it. It builds faster and is more pigmented than Black Honey, but it’s still easy to control. The formula is balmy and moisturizing and doesn’t have a scent that I notice. 

Best Glossy Brown That Actually Stays Brown: Charlotte Tilbury in 90s Kiss – This is one of the only sheer, balmy browns I’ve tried that stays a cool rosy brown instead of turning orange or becoming a generic pink. It has a little bit of purple, looks shiny without being too glossy, and feels really comfortable and easy to wear. I’ve also talked to several people who bought it and found that it stayed brown on them too, even if they had totally different undertones. 

Best Matte Brown That Actually Stays Brown: MAC Powder Kiss Hazy Matte Lipstick in Good For You – Good For You gives me the best cool tone ’90s brown color that I keep trying to buy without turning into another alleged brown that turns terracotta or Cheeto. The Powder Kiss Hazy Matte formula gives a very soft, blurred, diffused effect that’s really trending right now without being too drying, though it’s not as comfortable as some of the other mattes I’m about to mention. 

Best Matte Red: rom&nd Zero Matte Lipstick in 01 – This shade isn’t supposed to be red at all; it’s literally called Dusty PInk. So when I first put it on, I was like “uh what is this?” But it turns into a soft, muted, slightly warm red on me that actually looks right at home. The formula is extremely similar to the Merit Signature Lip Blushes (which I’ll get to in a bit), with the same lightweight, comfortable, genuinely blurring feel. It doesn’t need a liner and gives me a very easy, understated version of a red lip. 

Best Creamy Red: Lancôme L’Absolu Rouge in 265 – This was one of those immediate “okay, this is the red for me” lipsticks. It’s a deeper red with a slight purple undertone that still reads clearly red on me but looks completely at home with my coloring. The formula is lightweight, buildable, creamy, and nourishing with a soft satin finish. I prefer wearing it with a liner because it’s so creamy, but this is exactly what I’d choose for simple “French-girl” makeup with light eyeshadow, a little blush, and one really good red lip. Thank you to my pink friend Hunter for picking this one out for me! 

Best Color I Need in a Different Formula: Marc Jacobs Heart On Lipstick in Eat It Up – This color is still basically perfect. It’s a grungy, desaturated mauve with the brown purple depth I’m always trying to find, and the actual lipstick formula feels smooth and balmy. Unfortunately, it also leaves a horrible lingering taste that I truly can’t get past, so I need someone else to make this exact color in a product I can stand to wear. Gucci Rouge à Lèvres Satin Lipstick in 219 Mary Mauve is close, but it’s still not exactly the same. 

Best Formula I Need in Different Colors: Merit Signature Lip Blush in Vendôme, Bespoke, and Archival – When I first tried these, I immediately loved the sheer, lightweight, softly blurred matte formula. They’re comfortable, have just enough pigment, and mixing Bespoke and Archival gave me a really pretty everyday shade. But I eventually stopped reaching for all three because none of them look quite right on me, and I don’t want to mix two lipsticks every time I wear them. I know Bespoke looks like it’ll be a shade I’ll love, but it turns orange when mixed with my lip color. The formula is special, but I need Merit to make genuinely dusty mauves and cool berries. If they have and I just missed them, leave me a comment! 

Best Glossy Stain: Judydoll Ice Watery Lip Gloss Gen 2 in 11 and 18 – Judydoll wins because it’s the most hydrating and gives the glossiest, glassiest finish of all the stains I compared while still leaving behind a real stain. Shade 11 is my easy cool toned mauvey everyday shade, while 18 is an actual brown that stays brown instead of turning orange. The one thing to know is that these do have a noticeable watermelon scent.

I also wanted to include both ColourPop HydraPop Lip Stain in 90s Babe and NYX Lip I.V. as drugstore alternatives because y’all love a stain, and these are all great. ColourPop has no noticeable scent, and 90s Babe is an especially great everyday muted reddish rose. NYX is also hydrating and has a lot of fun shades (I have Petal Pourin, Grape Gushin, Hydra Honey, and Mocha Me Wet), although they tend to pull a little warmer on me and the finish isn’t quite as glassy.

Best Matte Stain: ETUDE Fixing Tint in 14 Rose Lilac and 15 Woody Pink – These remain my favorite matte lip stains because they give me the blurred finish I want without becoming dry, crusty, or uncomfortable. Woody Pink is an easy dusty rosy neutral, while Rose Lilac is a deeper, moodier jammy berry plum. Both can be tapped on lightly or built up. The finish looks smooth, the stain actually lasts, and they’re much more forgiving than a traditional long wearing liquid lipstick.

Best Blurred Lip: MAC Powder Kiss Lip + Cheek Mousse in Velvet Teddy, It’s Personal, and Rekindled – MAC wins because the formula is just slightly more plush and pillowy than the other blurred liquid lips I’ve tried while still feeling moisturizing and extremely comfortable. Velvet Teddy is an easy muted pink, It’s Personal is a very hard to find beige that doesn’t turn orange on me, and Rekindled is a very deep purple brown.

I’m including ColourPop Cloud Whip Blurring Liquid Lipstick in Storm Cloud as an honorary mention because it’s so similar. It’s only slightly less plush than MAC but also slightly more moisturizing, and Storm Cloud is such a beautiful deep, rusty purple brown that it’s worth having for the color alone. If the exact same shade existed in both formulas, I’d probably choose MAC, but ColourPop is close enough that I would happily pick up more Cloud Whips.

What would win your personal lipstick awards? As always, some products may have been gifted, but all reviews/opinions are completely my own and unsponsored.

I Bought 14 Risky Beauty Products Because I Needed to Know About These Colors

Today’s post is a collaboration with my amazing, incredibly talented friend Kathryn, who I’m sure you know already as Simply Swatched on Instagram or her website. We both love arm swatches, interesting colors, niche brands, and overanalyzing why the exact same shade can look completely different depending on someone’s undertone.

When I realized we had both independently bought the new Risky Blur-Rush Sticks, I reached out to see if she wanted to do a joint post reviewing everything we have from the brand, and luckily she said yes! We thought it would be fun to compare notes and turn the posts into a little undertone experiment. Make sure to check out her review for her thoughts on the products and to see how the shades look on her very fair, muted, neutral skin. Her swatches are also much better labeled than mine, and she does videos! Let us know if you’d like to see us do more comparisons like this – we love to buy too much makeup and write reviews!

Risky makes exactly the kinds of colors I’m always trying to find: muted mauves, grungy purples, genuinely cool browns, and purple blushes that allegedly stay purple. I bought all 14 products in this post myself because I needed to know what they’d all look like on me and have been testing them for the past few weeks.

In this post, all links are affiliate links (thank you for your support!), but all opinions are my own. Swatches are under a ring light to show true to color (photo #1) and then standard lighting to show the formula a little better (#2) for all the products.

Overall, Risky is more expensive than most American drugstore makeup, but still less expensive than most prestige makeup. YesStyle is also almost always running a sale and lets you stack codes too, which is one of the reasons I grabbed so many glosses. Most of the packaging is fun, functional, and feels more expensive than it is (except for the blush sticks, which are just…sticks).

Risky Be Bold Lip Glosses in Hissy Fit, Guilty, Sicko, Oddy, and Mumbly – These glosses are so good, and I’m honestly just very happy I own all five. These remind me of the liquid lip balm formulas everyone was obsessed with a few years ago. I’m still personally a huge fan of that type of formula, and these are such a good version of it. They feel buttery and smooth, make my lips look noticeably better, and give me a pretty shine without feeling sticky. They’re extremely comfortable and moisturizing, with just a slight cooling tingle. I also haven’t noticed any scent or taste that bothered me.

They last better than I expect a gloss to last. The color and visible shine eventually do wear away, but the nourishing feeling sticks around. I tested one while working on this review, washed my face, took a shower, and could still feel some of it on my lips afterward. I wouldn’t use one of these as an overnight treatment, but as a shiny daytime liquid lip balm, I am extremely impressed.

Hissy Fit is an perfect everyday, my-lips-but-better mauvy pink. It’s the most everyday shade of the five, but it still feels special because it actually stays mauve instead of drifting into peach or orange. Guilty is deeper and grungier, with a beautiful desaturated mauve/purple/brown tone. These are the two I’ve been wearing most often.

Sicko is much sheerer and gives me a translucent wash of desaturated gray-purple. It’s beautiful by itself, but I also love it for cooling down another lip color. Oddy is the sheer grape color I keep hoping to get from Clinique Black Honey type products, and it 100% delivers.

Mumbly is a cool toned brown gloss that stays cool instead of turning Cheeto or orange. This was the first shade I put on when these arrived because I don’t think I had ever tried a brown gloss that actually stayed this color on me. I don’t think everyone needs all five, but they’re each special, none of them go orange on me, and I would honestly buy all of them again.

Risky Blur-Rush Sticks in Tinut, Heartish, Mauvement, and Purpler – These have become some of the cream blushes I reach for most, and I honestly haven’t really touched my others since I got them. They’re so easy to throw on and blend, and they have a really pretty, skin like finish. They also layer really well so I can use them together to make a custom shade.

The formula is a little sheer and buildable, although the pigmentation varies by shade. Mauvement is softer and sheerer, while Purpler has noticeably more payoff. They’re easy to control if you’re paler than I am, but they also build up without much effort. My only complaint is that all four tubes look identical from the outside and the part of the packaging that matches the shade is inside, which isn’t particularly helpful when I’m trying to grab the right one.

Tinut is an orangey nude-beige that I bought specifically because I wanted to know whether it would be olive-friendly. On me, it has too much of that strange orange tone I’m always trying to avoid. It isn’t the worst Cheeto situation I’ve ever seen, but it’s the only one of the four I wouldn’t recommend. Heartish is the perfect brightening cool toned pink. It gives me a fresh springy or summery look without turning peach.

Mauvement is my perfect (really, PERFECT) cool, grungy, slightly gray and desaturated mauve. Purpler is a genuinely cool purple blush that stays purple instead of turning pink. It’s deeper and more pigmented than Mauvement, and this kind of purple looks so good against olive skin.

Risky Be Bold Lip Blushed in Moly, Thistle, and Peacock – Blurred K-beauty liquid lips are one of my favorite makeup categories, and these are no exception. The formula is super thin, smooth, and easy to wear. It gives me the soft, diffused matte effect I want without feeling dry or heavy. They’re a little sheerer than some similar formulas, which I actually really appreciate. I would rather gradually build a blurred lip than start with an extremely pigmented formula and end up with an AHHHH PIGMENT situation. They aren’t 20 hour bulletproof liquid lips, but they’re comfortable, easy to reapply, and leave behind a little bit of a stain as they fade.

Moly initially looks like a warm coral pink but in some lighting it does go Cheeto. It also has a little visible sparkle, which I don’t mind, but I also don’t understand. I will still wear it because sometimes I do want to wear orange on purpose. But if you’re buying Moly because it looks pink and you’re also a green friend, this is not for you.

Thistle is yet another cool toned mauve. It stays mauve, doesn’t go orange, and gives me exactly the easy blurred color I’m almost always looking for. Like the other mauves, Risky did a fantastic job. Peacock is a deep berry purple that actually stays purple instead of turning pink. Just like the blush, I love this kind of purple on my olive skin.

Risky Pigment Eyeshadow Palette in Harsh – This palette has eight eyeshadows, focused mainly on burgundy, pink, purple, and red tones. I find these colors surprisingly easy to use for everyday looks, especially because red plus green equals brown. These shades often look more better on me than a warm brown palettes that just ends up looking orange.

Compared with most of my other K-beauty eyeshadows, these are more pigmented, especially the deeper shades. The darker shades all have strong payoff, while the lighter shades are softer and useful for blending. The formula is consistently good, easy to blend, and flexible enough to apply with either my fingers or a brush. I don’t get much fallout or noticeable creasing, and it’s the kind of palette I can grab without worrying that the formula is going to cascade into a bunch of mistake fixing all morning. The shimmers are smooth and pretty rather than extremely intense or sparkly, but that’s been great for every day.

Risky Pigment Eyeshadow Palette in Cosmic Love – Cosmic Love is essentially a palette of eight sheer, sparkly toppers. There are two really pretty browns and then a bunch of fun colors. The base colors are fairly translucent, so I prefer wearing them over another shadow – I showed them all over black in the swatches so you can see how they transform over a darker base. I also recommend using a tackier glitter primer or glitter base to help with longevity especially if you’re wearing these alone.

These shades give you a really pretty, ethereal look, but with more sparkle than I usually get from this type of palette. If that’s what you want, I think this is a great option. For me, though, if I’m adding sparkle, I want SPARKLE. I’d rather put the money toward one or two really special shades from Half Magic, Hourglass, or Victoria Beckham.

What should I test next? As always, all reviews/opinions are completely my own and unsponsored.

The Best Pressed Setting and Finishing Powders for Dry Skin, Two Years Later

Two years ago, I wrote about my favorite setting and finishing powders for dry skin. Since then, I’ve tested a lot more powders, decluttered a lot of them, and gotten much pickier about what I actually want powder to do, so I went through everything again. I narrowed it down to 5 pressed powders and 11 loose powders. I’m starting with the pressed powders, and the loose powders are coming next because I had a lot more to say there with my recentish love of blue, green, lavender, and pink powders.

For this post, I’m focusing on pressed setting and finishing powders together because I tend to use very lightweight powders that are basically all finishing powders that also do a little setting. Two of these are still in my top picks from the last time I did this, and there are three other newer favorites that earned their spot in my collection.

In this post, all links are affiliate links (thank you for your support!), but all opinions are my own. I skipped swatches, and you’ll just have to trust me you really can’t see the differences in photos but I did try! 

Laura Mercier Ultra-Blur Talc-Free Waterproof Translucent Pressed Setting Powder in Translucent – This is still my favorite pressed powder for actually setting my makeup. I feel the exact same way about it that I did two years ago, which is that no matter what I do, it never feels like I put too much of this on. It sets just enough, takes down shine just enough, and never makes my dry skin look heavy, cakey, or flat.

The biggest thing for me is that it’s actually translucent. It doesn’t add coverage, change the color of my makeup, or make anything pull weird on my olive skin. It does have a tendency to hard pan, but you can easily fix that with a piece of tape. I wouldn’t recommend this if you have oily skin and want serious oil control. It’s only doing a small amount of setting and mattifying. But for dry skin, especially if you want powder without looking powdered, it’s still the one I reach for the most.

*You can use YOURGREENFRIEND for 20% off on the Laura Mercier website, which I’m pretty sure happened specifically because I love this powder and talk about it all the time. Thank you as always for your support and making it so I can do this!

Kosas Cloud Set Baked Setting & Smoothing Talc-Free Powder in Airy – This is also still one of my favorites, and I’m 0% surprised. If the Laura Mercier is my favorite true pressed setting powder, Kosas is the one I reach for when I want something softer and a little more finishing powder adjacent. It has a tiny bit of coverage, a tiny bit of glow, and it smooths everything out without taking the life out of my skin. I have the shade Airy, and on me it doesn’t pull orange, peachy, dusty, or dry. It just makes my makeup look a little softer and more finished.

Compared to Laura Mercier, this feels more like makeup in the best way because it adds that little bit of coverage that the Laura Mercier doesn’t. I still use both constantly. Laura Mercier is the one I grab when I want the most invisible setting, and Kosas is the one I grab when I want my skin to look smoother and a little more perfected.

Givenchy Prisme Libre Blurring & Color-Correcting Matte Pressed Powder in 3 Voile Rosé – The Givenchy loose powder I talked about in my original post was discontinued, which is rude because it was absolutely perfect. I’ve tried a lot of powders since then, and while nothing is exactly the same as the original loose Prisme Libre, the pressed version in 3 Voile Rosé gets very close.

I’ve reviewed this before and said it was about 95% of the way there, and I still feel that way. It blurs, lightly mattifies, and brightens without making my dry skin look powdery. It’s especially good for summer dry skin because it takes down just enough shine without turning everything matte.

This shade gives me a little bit of brightening, but it doesn’t look obviously pink or chalky on me. It’s not doing a ton of oil control, so if you want a powder powder for oily skin, this probably isn’t it. But if you loved the original Givenchy loose powder and want a pressed version that captures a lot of what made that formula special, this is the closest thing I’ve found.

CANMAKE Marshmallow Finish Powder Abloom in 03 Plumeria Wreath – Annnnd this is the powder that made me realize I didn’t actually need the Givenchy pressed powder. Don’t get me wrong, I’m glad I have the Givenchy. It’s beautiful. It feels fancy, and I love using it. But the CANMAKE Marshmallow Finish Powder gives me such a similar effect that I use them interchangeably. If I used this and the Givenchy with my eyes closed, I’m pretty confident I wouldn’t be able to tell the difference on my face. The Givenchy is gorgeous, but I’d be just as happy with the CANMAKE, and it’s so much less expensive.

It has that same smooth, softly blurred, slightly glowy but not actually glittery finish. It takes down shine without making my skin look dry, and it makes my makeup look more polished without looking like I added a visible layer of powder. I have shade 03, which has pink, yellow, white, green, and blue in the compact. That combination works really well for me because it brightens without turning chalky, pink, peach, or weird on my olive skin. 

Hourglass Ambient Lighting Palette Volume 1 – This is the powder I use all the time and never talk about because it’s $75, but going through all my powders reminded me how much I really do love this palette. Volume 1 has mini pans of Dim Light, Incandescent Light, and Radiant Light. You can use the shades separately, but I usually just mix all three together and use it as my final step.

This isn’t really a setting powder for me. It’s my one true finishing powder. I use it when I want my skin to look airbrushed, when I want everything to blend together, or when I’ve finished my makeup and it just needs that last smoothing layer.

This just makes my skin and my makeup look better, so it’s really an investment in all my other products. That’s how I’m justifying it, and honestly, I stand by it. This is also the powder I reach for when I’m having trouble blending cheek products together but don’t want to add more blush, bronzer, or coverage. It smooths everything together without adding obvious color. Of all my finishing powders, if I could only keep one, it would be this.

What’s your favorite pressed powder right now?  As always, all reviews/opinions are completely my own and unsponsored.

Reviewing Products You Asked Me to Test: Viral Cushions, Perfect Pink and Mauve Blushes, and a Possible Marc Jacobs Eat It Up Dupe

I’ve been slowly testing products that people asked me to test since y’all loved the first edition of this post. I finally have thoughts to share on these two cushion foundations, two blushes, and a lipstick that a few of you asked me to grab in my ongoing attempt to find an alternative to Marc Jacobs Eat It Up. I’m planning on doing this every month, prioritizing chat members’ requests, but I’m always on the look out for things to review!

In this post, all links are affiliate links (thank you for your support!), but all opinions are my own. Swatches are under a ring light to show true to color (photo #1) and then standard lighting to show the formula a little better (#2) for all the products.

TIRTIR Mask Fit Aura Cushion in 21W and Parnell Cicamanu Serum Cushion in 23W – I’ve been working through testing four cushion foundations, and so far these are my top two picks by a mile. One of the other cushions I’ve been testing is the TIRTIR Mask Fit Red Cushion that I keep seeing everywhere. I don’t recommend that one for dry skin, and a bunch of people told me to try the Mask Fit Aura Cushion instead. It’s way better but between the TIRTIR Aura and the Parnell, Parnell easily wins for me.

I did a few side by side tests with Parnell on one side and TIRTIR Aura on the other, then asked my husband which side looked better. He picked the Parnell side every time. It looks beautiful on the skin, doesn’t break up weirdly, lasts well all day, and makes my skin look better. The TIRTIR Aura is still much better than the Red Cushion, but I find it can break up more throughout the day and just doesn’t look quite as good even on first application.

Shade-wise, TIRTIR Aura in 21W is the closest match I’ve found so far across all the cushion foundations I’ve tried. It’s on the edge of being too light, and it’s still a little yellow, but it’s workable. I tried 20N in another cushion foundation and that was definitely too light so I know I’m getting close. Because 21W was a little light, I picked up 23W in the Parnell. The depth is better, but the shade itself is a little too orange. I’m betting 23N would be a better match for me, but I can make 23W work with a little blue corrector. The good news is that I can wear both the TIRTIR Aura and Parnell without it being too obvious that the shades are off. They blend in well enough, especially if I’m just tapping them on and going.

Dolce&Gabbana Cherry Glaze Bar 24H Glow Blush Stick in Demure Rose – This is one of the products I got the most questions about because it went viral, and everyone wanted to know if any of the shades were actually olive-friendly. I can confirm that Demure Rose is a really pretty everyday pink, but I wouldn’t call it “demure”. In a heavy swatch, it looks much brighter than the name suggests. It’s more of a pinky red than a muted rose. Once it’s blended out, it becomes a very beautiful rosy pink with a lot of glow. It’s still a little warmer than my ideal blush, and I’d absolutely buy a mauvier version if Dolce&Gabbana made one, but this doesn’t turn into the peachy orange situation I’m always trying to avoid. 

The formula is also why I keep reaching for it. You can swipe it on, tap it on, or pick it up with a brush. It’s pretty pigmented, so I usually prefer to swipe a brush across the stick and then apply it that way instead of drawing it directly onto my face. The finish is the best part. It has this beautiful glowy sheen that makes my skin look better, but not in a glittery or greasy way. One day while I was testing it, my husband asked if I was wearing highlighter because my skin looked so glowy, and it was literally just that this blush makes my skin look so nice. It also sets down and lasts all day while maintaining its glowiness, which is really hard to find! 

nuse Mousse Care Cheek Handy in 05 Dimdumb – This is usually around $10 on YesStyle, and I’m so happy that a bunch of you told me to buy it while I’ve been on my hunt for the perfect muted mauve blush. I wanted something cool-toned, soft, mauve, easy to wear, and nowhere near orange. I don’t want every review to turn into “you need to run and buy this immediately,” because most of the time, you really don’t. But this is one of the rare times where I’m going to say it anyway: if you’ve been looking for this exact kind of blush, you need to get this.

The color is perfect. It’s one of the only times I’ve bought something described as a soft mauve and it actually showed up as a soft mauve on me. It doesn’t turn peach. It doesn’t turn orange. It doesn’t become weirdly bright pink. It’s just this beautiful muted mauve that looks so at home on my skin. I also love the formula. It’s a liquid blush, but it sets down into this skin-like satin finish that looks beautiful and wears really well. It’s easy to work with, it’s buildable, it dries down, and it lasts all day. I have a bunch of nuse blushes now, and I’m probably going to keep buying more because the formula is exactly the kind of thing I want from an everyday blush.

Compared to the Dolce&Gabbana Cherry Glaze Bar, these are very different products for very different purposes. The Dolce&Gabbana is glossy, glowy, and more of a fresh summer pink. The nuse is softer, cooler, more muted, and much more “perfect everyday mauve blush.” I’m very happy to have both. But if you’re looking for a liquid mauve blush under $15, I can’t recommend this one enough. This might be my favorite blush shade I’ve found all year.

Gucci Rouge à Lèvres Satin Lipstick in 219 Mary Mauve – The last product I picked up because you all asked me to is the Gucci Rouge à Lèvres Satin Lipstick in 219 Mary Mauve, mostly because I’ve been trying to find something with the same general vibe as the Marc Jacobs Heart On lipstick in Eat It Up but without the taste (I really can’t handle it, and I’m still jealous if you can).

In swatches, these aren’t exact dupes. Gucci 219 is redder and rosier while Eat It Up has more of that brown-purple depth that made me love the shade in the first place. But on the lips, they’re close enough that I really don’t think most people would notice the difference. And I love color nuance of course. But if you wanted the same moody, wearable, not-orange lipstick feeling and couldn’t deal with the Marc Jacobs taste, Gucci 219 is a really good alternative. The formula is also equally nice, though the Gucci is a little less balmy. The one thing I’ll say is that the Gucci lipstick is also fragranced, but it bothers me much less than the Marc Jacobs taste.

What should I test for the next round? As always, all reviews/opinions are completely my own and unsponsored.

I Tested 11 MAC Blushes on Olive Skin and Found the Grungy Blush Adjuster I Didn’t Know I Needed

I specifically bought the newer MAC powder blushes and one of the Strobe Beam Liquid Blushes because I wanted to see how the current MAC blush lineup works on olive skin. Are the pinks actually pink? Are the “plummy” shades actually plum? Do the deeper, more interesting colors stay nuanced, or do they turn into the same warm peachy-orange situation I’m always trying to avoid?

I also already owned five Glow Play blushes from years ago that I’m reviewing in this post because I wanted to put everything in one place. These aren’t the reason I’m doing this post, but they ended up being useful because they showed me how much my blush preferences have changed. I also have a couple of the new MAC bronzers, but I’m saving those for a bigger olive undertone bronzer deep dive. Let me know if you want that post sooner rather than later! 

In this post, all links are affiliate links (thank you for your support!), but all opinions are my own. Swatches are under a ring light to show true to color (photo #1) and then standard lighting to show the formula a little better (#2) for all the products. 

Skinfinish Colourstruck Blush in Desert Rose, Velvet Teddy, Antique Velvet, and Film Noir Buff – The newer Skinfinish Colourstruck blushes are buildable, blendable, matte powder blushes. They’re super hard to swatch, but they do work really well on the face. Compared with the older MAC matte blush formula, these pick up more easily, blend better, and look smoother on the skin. I still reach for cream, liquid, or bouncy hybrid formulas much more often, but these are solid for a traditional matte blush formula. 

Desert Rose is a very pretty light pink. It’s easy, brightening, and it doesn’t turn aggressively orange on me. I have other bright pinks where I prefer the formula, but I still grab this as a finishing touch when my face needs a little more life.

Velvet Teddy is described as a deep-toned beige, but on me this is pink. Where’s the beige? It’s slightly deeper and more grounded than Desert Rose, with a little more warmth. It can go orangey on me, but not enough to be Cheeto dust, and it’s still really pretty when I’m going for a pink look, especially in the summer. 

I bought Antique Velvet because Kackie bought it, and I wanted to see what it would do. On me, this is less soft purple veil like in the online swatches and more weird bronze with the slightest hint of plum. As a one-and-done eyeshadow, it’s actually really pretty. As a blush, it’s interesting but not one I’d recommend if you’re a skin twin unless you’ve really been looking for this kind of shade. 

Film Noir Buff is the shade I’ve used the most, and if I were only keeping one matte blush from this collection, it would be this one. It’s a deep plummy purple-brown, and alone it can actually look a little too cool, grey, and deep on me, which almost never happens. As a blush mixer, this is a keep forever shade. I have so many blushes that looked like they were going to be muted, beige, plum, nude, or purple, and then turned orange on my face. Film Noir Buff pulls them back toward something more beigey, brown, a little purple, and way more wearable.

The one that made me the most excited about Film Noir Buff is NARS Infatuated. It looks like it should be a deep plummy purple and is described as a “deep plumberry”, and on me it’s just orange. I keep trying to make it work so I keep it around, and it’s always still orange. BUT! When I layer Film Noir Buff with it, I finally get the beigey rosy brown blush I’ve always wanted. I’ve mixed Film Noir Buff with so many blushes at this point, and it’s really so perfect for that. 

Matte Powder Blush in Blunt – I didn’t realize until writing this that the old MAC matte powder blushes are discontinued, so Blunt is mostly here as a comparison point. It’s a muted rosy tan/brown that gives me an easy everyday blush look that’s not orange. That said, the formula isn’t amazing relative to what we have now. Compared with the newer Skinfinish Colourstruck blushes, Blunt looks and feels drier, flatter, and less blurring. I’m still keeping it because I love the color, and I’ve used it as an eyeshadow all the time. If anyone has a good Blunt replacement, especially in a bouncy, cushiony, cream to powder texture, please let me know! 

Strobe Beam Liquid Blush in Plummy Bare – I picked up one of the Strobe Beam Liquid Blushes because I’d heard so many good things about the formula, and Plummy Bare seemed like the safest shade for me. I wear plum, berry, blackberry, and purple blush all the time. But Plummy Bare isn’t really that. In the comparison swatch, it’s the first shade, and next to my actual berry/plum blushes, you can see how red it is. It’s a super pretty cool toned deep red, almost like a muted wine shade (it’s described as a deep cherry wine, and I think I expected more cherry). If that’s what you want, it’s beautiful. I just expected something more plum, blackberry, or bright berry.

I do really like the formula. It’s pigmented, a little glowy, and easy to blend. Because this shade is deeper and more intense, I put a little on the back of my hand first, pick it up with a brush, and then tap it onto the cheeks instead of dotting it straight onto my face. It blends nicely, but a little goes a long way.

If you want an actual plumberry blush, I’d rather use Rare Beauty Soft Pinch Liquid Blush in Faith or Glow Recipe Dewy Flush Berry Flush. Berry Flush still has redness to it, but because it sheers out, it reads more berry on me. If you want something brighter and pinker but still with that blue purple tone, Sacheu Liquid Blush in I’m Bold is closer.

Glow Play Blush in Grand, So Natural, True Harmony, Blush Please, and Totally Synced – I already owned all five of these blushes, and most of them are at least four years old, if not older (so keep in mind that they are probably somewhat expired). When I first bought them, I loved them. At the time, this bouncy, cushiony blush texture felt much less common, and the formula was so much easier and more forgiving than a traditional matte powder blush. But now this kind of formula is everywhere, and my shade preferences are completely different. Pulling these back out made me realize that most of the shades I own are way warmer than I want.

Grand is a pretty pink, but on me it can go corally orange really fast. There are so many cool toned pinks out now that don’t lean coral that I never reach for this one anymore even though it’s definitely one of my most used from over the years.   

So Natural is coral on me in a “why does that look so weird on my skin” kind of way. If you’re looking for a super easy to wear coral, this is pretty, but it’s definitely not what I’m going for anymore. 

True Harmony is a really pretty rosy brown in some lighting,  but it can also go orange on me. I like the idea of this shade more than I like wearing it now, and I always put it on expecting it to work and then it’s just a little too warm. 

Blush Please is another pink that also has that coral-orange shift I’m trying to avoid. It’s less corally than Grand, which actually makes it less useful because at least Grand is something I specifically use for bright, summery, pinky warm looks, whereas Blush Please is just…fine. I will say if you’re not olive, this is such a perfect everyday pink blush. I’ve used it on my friends for their wedding makeup, and it’s been great every time. 

Totally Synced is the only one of these I’m considering keeping. It’s a cool toned lavender lilac, and I still use it all the time to brighten up a look or add a little pop of color. This kind of shade used to feel hard to find, and even though now I own a bunch of blushes in this general color family, I don’t think I can let Totally Synced go.  

As always, all reviews/opinions are completely my own and unsponsored. 

I’ve Been Hunting for Grungy and Fun Lip Products, and MAC Had Them the Whole Time

I’ve been testing a lot of lip products because I’m always looking for shades that are interesting, a little grungy, and not secretly orange. A shade can be described as cool nude, mauve, taupe, plum, brown, berry, or purple, and then somehow it turns into a warm peachy/orange on my face. So I keep buying blue glosses, purple adjusters, cool browns, blackberry lipsticks, and anything that looks like it might help me get the lip color I wanted in the first place.

It turns out MAC has actual blue, purple, blackened, grungy, makeup artisty colors, which I love. But they also have easy everyday shades that actually stay the color they’re supposed to be on me. Cool pinks that don’t turn coral. Mauves that don’t turn peach. Browns that don’t go orange. Glosses that add shine without warming everything up too much. *I did also grab some really cool and interesting lip products from Yesstyle that y’all recommended so more reviews coming soon.

In this post, all links are affiliate links (thank you for your support!), but all opinions are my own. Swatches are under a ring light to show true to color (photo #1) and then standard lighting to show the formula a little better (#2) for all the products.

Here are all the bullet lipsticks together just so you can see the formulas and colors all together in both lightings.

Lustreglass Sheer-Shine Lipstick in Alone Time, Signature Move, and Succumb to Plum – This is my favorite MAC lip formula and the one I reach for the most overall. It’s balmy and glossy, but it still gives enough color that it feels like a real lipstick. It’s easy to throw on, it makes my lips look better, and it wears surprisingly well for something this comfortable. I also recently compared Alone Time to the Clé de Peau Cocoa Dahlia lipstick, and they were shockingly close. So if you want that sheer, balmy, shiny, expensive feeling lipstick effect, I would absolutely look at MAC Lustreglass before spending $70 on Clé de Peau.

Alone Time is the best mauvey brown I’ve found. It stays mauve on me instead of turning orange, even in different lighting, and it has that grungy tan mauve quality I’m always looking for. This is one of the MAC lip products I reach for the most. Signature Move is similar to Alone Time, but a little more brown and a little warmer. It has more red in it, and it can lean slightly more orange by comparison, though it’s still very wearable. I like it, but if I were only choosing one, I’d choose Alone Time. Succumb to Plum a deep, saturated cool plum that actually stays cool toned. It’s the boldest of the Lustreglass shades I have, but the formula keeps it glossy and soft enough to wear all the time. This is the one I reach for when I want something darker, more blackberry, and more interesting without going all the way to black lipstick.

M·A·Cximal Sleek Satin Lipstick in Pink Peppermint and Tilted Denim and M·A·Cximal Silky Matte Lipstick in Caviar – These are my go to adjuster shades. I use them less as traditional lipsticks because they’re really amazing problem solvers. If a lipstick is too orange, too yellow, too bright, too dark or too light, or just not quite right on me, these are the shades I start tapping on top.

The M·A·Cximal Sleek Satin formula feels like the most traditional lipstick formula of all of these. It’s full coverage, very pigmented, and comfortable, with a little bit of shine so it doesn’t look flat. It’s not as balmy or glossy as Lustreglass, but it gives much more opacity. Caviar is in the M·A·Cximal Silky Matte formula, so it’s flatter and more matte than Pink Peppermint and Tilted Denim. In the swatches, you can see the satin shades have a little bit of shine, while Caviar is much more matte.

Pink Peppermint is described as a dusty lavender, but on me it reads more like a cool pink with a little purple in it. I use this all the time to transition lipsticks that are too yellow, too orange, or too dark. It’s my quick fix shade when I don’t want to do a whole mixing experiment, because it makes almost everything look better.

Tilted Denim is blue, but it has some lavender/periwinkle tones in it, so it works really well as a cooling adjuster. When I have a lipstick where I like the general tone but it pulls too orange, especially with reds, I can tap on a little Tilted Denim and mix it in. It’s not an everyday lipstick shade on its own for me, but as an adjuster it’s so incredibly useful.

Caviar is a black with some green/blue/olive in it, and I use it when something is too bright or needs more depth. A tiny amount tapped in can make a lipstick look cooler, moodier, and more like the deep blackberry, purple, blackened lip colors I’m always trying to find. I also like wearing it lightly with gloss over top because it gives that sheer blackened lip effect without needing a separate lipstick.

M·A·Cximal Silky Matte Lipstick in Smoked Purple and Mehr and Powder Kiss Hazy Matte Lipstick in Good For You – These are the matte lipsticks I wear as actual lipsticks. MAC has a lot of matte lipstick formulas, and these three feel very different. As I mentioned with Caviar, the M·A·Cximal Silky Matte formula is matte, full coverage, and almost drying. For some reason, Mehr formula feels creamier and more traditional satin lipstick that just dries down a little matte than Smoked Purple and Caviar, maybe because it’s a mini. Either way, I’m not sure I agree with their description that these are “creamy” but they are a comfortable matte. The Powder Kiss Hazy Matte formula gives a very soft, blurred, diffused effect that’s really trending right now without being too drying.

Smoked Purple is a gorgeous deep cool purple that actually stays purple on me with no orange at all. If I want a true dramatic deep purple lip, this is the one. Mehr is a classic for a reason. It’s a really easy cool toned pink with a bit of blue in it, and it actually stays cool on me. Good For You is a cool toned brown that stays brown instead of turning orange, which makes it basically the perfect 90s brown lipstick for me.

Powder Kiss Lip + Cheek Mousse in It’s Personal, Velvet Teddy, and Rekindled – This is one of my favorite soft focus, blurring matte liquid formulas. It works well on lips and cheeks for a super quick and easy monochromatic look. It has such a pretty diffused finish without feeling dry or reminding me of a flat liquid lipstick. It’s much softer and easier to wear than the liquid lipsticks of yesteryear.

It’s Personal really surprised me. Everyone said it was the perfect light beigey pink nude, and even though it’s described as cool, I assumed it would somehow still turn orange on me. But it actually stays a really pretty light beigey pink. In very warm light, it can go more beigey brown, but it never turns into that bright neon orange Cheeto dust I hate. Especially if you’re a fair olive and want an easy nude in this formula, this is the one I’d absolutely recommend.

Velvet Teddy is a super easy to throw on cool toned pink. It’s simple, flattering, and very wearable, especially if you like having a dependable muted pink around. It doesn’t go orange, it doesn’t feel too warm, and it’s just pretty.

Rekindled is a dark purple brown, and it definitely brings more drama. It’s grungy, moody, and really pretty, especially if you like deeper lip colors or have more contrast. I wouldn’t call it the easiest everyday shade (you can see in the swatches I had a little trouble getting it to blend cleanly), but if you want a purple brown that’s grungy and still pretty, this is great. Just be a little careful applying – I’d recommend putting some on the back of your hand and then using a brush.

Lipglass Cushion High-Pigment Lip Oil in Yum Yum and Dressed To Dazzle – This formula is so, so good. It has solid pigment payoff without being too much for a gloss, it’s high shine, and even though it’s described as a lip oil, it feels more like a cushiony liquid lip balm. It’s comfortable, moisturizing, and glossy without being sticky. Both shades I have also have these pretty iridescent sparkles running through them, but they’re still smooth instead of obvious gritty glitter. I’ve used both of these a ton already even when I was trying to test other things (oops!). I’m honestly about to buy Pulse and Mauvement as I’m looking at the listing for these so let me know if you want me to report back!

Yum Yum is a classic cool toned pink with a purpley blue sparkle, and it’s so easy to wear. I like it on its own, but I also use it to top off lipsticks that are a little off, especially if I want to cool them down slightly or brighten them up without changing them too much. It’s pretty, fun, and one of those glosses I can throw on without thinking. Dressed To Dazzle is described as a taupe lilac with iridescent pearls, but on me it reads more like a rosy brown than a lilac. That said, it’s beautiful and extremely wearable. If I want an easy beige-y glossy lip, this is the one I reach for all the time.

Squirt Plumping Gloss Stick in Violet Beta and Nova – These are the other glossy balm type products I have from MAC, and I mostly bought them because they come in fun colors that actually stay that color. Instead of using a clear balm or clear gloss for moisture and shine, I like being able to add a little purple or blue to tone down lip colors that pull too yellow, too orange, or too warm. As a very green olive person, it’s one of the things that I’m always looking for more of.

Violet Beta actually looks purple. I can wear it alone because I like cool toned lips, but it’s also useful layered over lipsticks that need a little cooling down. It adds shine and moisture while also making other colors more wearable for me. Nova really does show up blue and doesn’t turn pink or do anything weird – it’s just blue. Like Violet Beta, I can wear it alone, but I mostly like having it as a glossy blue adjuster instead of reaching for a clear balm. It’s great when something is too yellow or orange and I want to shift it cooler without doing a full lipstick mixing situation.

The main thing to know is that these are definitely tingly and plumping. That sensation doesn’t bother me personally, but I would skip these if you hate plumping glosses or if your lips are dry and sensitive.

Lip Pencil in Whirl – I’m including this mostly for completeness because it’s the only MAC lip liner I have. I swatched it next to the other lip liners I reach for most (in this order): Merit Brownstone, Merit Bauhaus, Maybelline Gone Greige, Thrive Kackie, Glossier Buff, Ravie Almond, and Ravie Mocha.

Next to those, Whirl is much pinker. If you collect grungy brown, rusty beige, cool contour, or purple lip liners and you want something that reads more like a true pink, Whirl is your girl. I tend to prefer cooler browns because they actually add shape to my lips, so this one wasn’t quite what I wanted. I thought it would be deeper and more contoury because it’s described as a “dirty rose”, but on me, it’s just pink.

The formula is fine and very much in line with a classic lip pencil. If MAC lip liners are on sale and you already know you want a shade, I don’t think it’s bad. But personally, the Merit lip liner formula is still my favorite because it’s easier to use, blends out nicely, sets, and doesn’t get as dry as some traditional liners. If I lost Whirl, I wouldn’t replace it, but if I lost my Merit lip liners, I absolutely would.

What fun lip products should I check out? As always, all reviews/opinions are completely my own and unsponsored.