Lisa Eldridge vs. Laura Mercier: I Finally Found Eyeshadow Sticks That I’m Excited to Wear

I love the idea of eyeshadow sticks because you can just draw them on, blend a little bit, and then you’re good to go. I actually own a bunch of eyeshadow sticks and have tried so many over the years, but I just don’t reach for them that much over eyeshadow palettes and singles, liquid shadows, etc. It honestly takes a lot for me to fall in love with a traditional eyeshadow stick; the colors just never seem to quite work right for me. But y’all really, really wanted me to review the new Lisa Eldridge Cream Shadow sticks so I bought Quartz and Smokey Amethyst to test. Then Laura Mercier sent me their newest Caviar Stick collection (Sephora, Ulta, Laura Mercier) in gifting (thank you!). I wasn’t expecting to fall in love with some of the Laura Mercier shades after years of trying eyeshadow sticks that were perfectly good but never quite right for my olive undertones. After talking about the Laura Mercier ones so much, I shouldn’t be surprised that my #1 request now is to compare them.

They’re both $34 (although Laura’s are less with their sale + my code), have very similar formulas, and wear almost exactly the same on me. The big difference is in the colors, so this post is essentially a deep dive into these eight shades. I swatched these built up and sheered out and included a video.

In this post, all links are affiliate links (thank you for your support!), but all opinions are my own. You can also use YOURGREENFRIEND for 20% off on the Laura Mercier website if you decide to shop! Swatches are under a ring light to show true to color (photo #1) and then standard lighting to show the formula a little better (#2) for all the products.

Before we get into the individual shades, some quick notes about each formula. The Laura Mercier formula is slightly thinner and has a smoother glide, while the Lisa Eldridge formula is a little thicker and feels slightly heavier. The Laura Mercier shimmers are also just a little sparklier. These are super subtle differences that I barely notice on my eyes, and once you blend them out, they’re practically interchangeable. Neither of these formulas is particularly revolutionary as far as eyeshadow sticks go, but if you love the idea of eyeshadow sticks and have struggled with finding the right colors, I think both collections are worth looking at.

I tested blending these with fingers and brushes and didn’t have any issues with any of the shades. I also tested with and without primer and didn’t notice much of a difference. I’m a primer girl so I still prefer using one, but both formulas work great without. Both formulas give plenty of blending time before they set, and then they are very set. I’ve been aggressively rubbing my arm swatches and literally nothing is moving. I have the same experience on my eyes – these all wear exceedingly well on me, and my eyelids love to eat eyeshadow. I don’t have hooded or oily eyelids so keep that in mind, but I was really impressed by the lack of creasing, fading, or fallout. If you love the promise of liquid shadows but can’t find one that will stay, I think these shimmer eyeshadow sticks are a good option to try. And if you’re looking for a matte option, I also found that the two Laura Mercier matte shades layered and built up particularly beautifully, maybe even better than the shimmers.

Even though these aren’t the easiest to remove given how well they set down, my normal double cleansing process has worked great. I’m currently loving the combo of the Remedy Cleansing Oil and Youth to the People cleanser, especially for slightly harder to remove long wear makeup.

Okay, on to the shades:

Laura Mercier Tailored Denim is a really pretty sky blue matte that reminds me of all of my favorite light blue nail polishes. When it’s sheered out, it’s a very soft muted blue, but you can build it up to a very bright blue. It’s surprisingly wearable when it’s sheered out and is also really fun to use as an accent shade. I’m not personally very experienced or confident with wearing blue eyeshadow, so I’ve really appreciated having such an easy formula and color to play around with. Would I have bought this myself? No, definitely not. But if you’re looking for a color like this, I think you’d be really happy with this one.

Laura Mercier Pink Suede is a matte soft pink that I initially thought would be the perfect base for pink, purple, and mauve eyeshadow looks. Ultimately, it’s a little too peachy on my olive skin. Like the blue shade though, the matte formula is fantastic – it’s smooth, easy to build, and easy to blend. It also layers really well. Neither of these matte shades is quite what I’m looking for, but playing with them has made me really want to find my perfect matte Caviar Stick shade.

Lisa Eldridge Quartz is a very yellow-leaning gold metallic on me. Based on the brand’s photos, I expected something much bronzier. Whatever my skin does to it, it just doesn’t quite harmonize with my undertones in the way that I had hoped. I know this is someone’s perfect sophisticated everyday golden bronzey metallic shade, but I am not that person. It does have a beautifully smooth reflective finish that just looks really nice on the eyes.

Laura Mercier Mixed Metals is a bronzy metallic that has a distinctly green, muted olive undertone. It’s the closest shade comparison I have to Quartz in that it’s going for that bronzy metal vibe, just…green. As a green friend, I love that about Mixed Metals. It works so well with my undertones to create an everyday bronze with dimension instead of generic gold. It’s beautiful alone, and I especially love this as a topper over a neutral or cool toned brown base. In person, this is also a little sparklier than Quartz, but the big difference really is the color. Of all the Laura Mercier shades, this is one of the ones I’d absolutely buy with my own money, and I’ve loved using it.

Laura Mercier Camo Trench is very green with a beautiful golden shimmer while Mixed Metals is a green leaning bronze. I’ve really been enjoying this shade of green for an inner corner pop of color on an otherwise brown only eye look or as a very fun eyeliner. It also does work really well all over my lid, and I think it’s super pretty. Like some of these other shades, I think it’s more suited to spring and summer. I’m excited though to have a green that doesn’t go lime or grey or do anything else weird. I wouldn’t have bought this myself (similar to why I didn’t buy Peridot from Lisa), but I’m actually loving having this shade in my collection.

Laura Mercier Port Leather turns into the most beautiful burgundy-brown on my skin that I can build up to be more burgundy/red or sheer out to be more brown. I absolutely love this shade so much. Because it’s more of a satin metallic than a super sparkly shade, it’s really easy to use this in a bunch of different ways. I’ve been constantly using this shade on the outer corner/outer third of my eye to create depth and dimension, and it’s been amazing to have a warmish brown that doesn’t go orange. I’ve also seen a bunch of folks experimenting with this under other shimmer shades, and I’m so excited to keep playing with it. This is another one I would buy with my own money, and I will probably need to when I use it up.

Laura Mercier Lavender Slip is such a pretty bright, springy lavender that’s visibly purple without going brown or bronze. It has such a beautiful delicate sparkle that I find really special. I’ve honestly loved building whole looks around this shade and have been wearing it all the time even though it’s November. This paired with Mixed Metals and a pink blush just makes me feel so happy and pretty, and I can’t wait to wear that combo all the time in the actual spring. This is the third of these eight that I would definitely buy with my own money. And if you’re looking for a fun purple eyeshadow stick in one of these releases, this is the one I’d recommend.

Lisa Eldridge Smokey Amethyst is the shade I’m genuinely disappointed in. I was expecting an interesting, smoky, nuanced bronzy-purple. On my skin, this is really more of a golden taupe that has a little bit of purple in it in certain lighting. For the most part, it just reads as a deeper gold than Quartz. It’s a beautiful gold in a beautiful formula that wears really well, but on me, it just doesn’t look quite the way I had hoped. It actually reminds me a lot of when the Victoria Beckham Orchid palette went orange instead of staying purple. I know my skin can make almost anything turn brown or orange, but I was really expecting this one to stay more purple. And I’m sure there are plenty of people it actually stays purple on! But if you tend to have the same color translation issues I do, this is likely not the bronzy purple of your dreams.

Have you tried either launch? And have you found an eyeshadow stick shade that actually looks the way you hoped it would on your skin?

Leave a Reply